Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Critics Say Anti-Semitism Bill Infringes On 1st Amendment By Banning Criticism Of Israel

The Star of David.
Alex Proimos
Wikimedia Commons
The Star of David.

Critics of a Florida House bill that aims to crack down on anti-Semitism say the legislation is too narrow because it fails to address other forms of xenophobia and hate crimes, and that it violates the First Amendment by criminalizing legitimate criticisms of the State of Israel.

HB 741, which would specify that the term “religion” include anti-Semitism for purposes of the hate crime statute, among other things, passed unanimously in the Criminal Justice Subcommittee Tuesday morning.

The bill is sponsored by Representatives Randy Fine (R-Brevard County), who is Jewish, and Michael Caruso (R-Delray Beach). The cosponsors are Representatives Jason Fischer (R-Jacksonville), Chip LaMarca (R-Lighthouse Point) and Spencer Roach (R-North Fort Myers).

Rep. Fine told members of the Criminal Justice Subcommittee that he filed the bill in response to a recent uptick in anti-Semitism. “As we have seen in recent weeks, unfortunately, anti-Semitism is alive and well in this country,” he said. “You can see it in the mainstreaming of certain language that’s been used in Washington D.C.”

“I'm not Jewish, but I stand here with Fine because it doesn't take being Jewish to know what's right and wrong,” Rep. Caruso added. “Anti-Semitism is a genocidal hatred that led to the death of over six million Jews, and it didn't end with the Holocaust.”

Fine said the bill, with an amendment introduced Tuesday morning, will do three main things: “The first thing that the bill will do is it will take the federal definition of anti-Semitism, the most widespread used definition of anti-Semitism in the world, and make it the Florida definition of anti-Semitism. The second thing the bill does is it requires all K-20 public institutions treat anti-Semitism in the same way that they treat racism on their college campuses, identifying the intersectionality of racism and anti-Semitism. And then the last thing that it does is it says that as it comes to our educational policy, you can't discriminate on religion of any kind as it relates to our public educational institutions.”

The bill also cites what it calls “examples of anti-Semitism related to Israel,” which includes “blaming Israel for all inter-religious or political tensions” and “focusing peace or human rights investigations only on Israel.”

“In modern times, anti-Semitism is sometimes disguised as anti-Zionism, anti-Israel. But the two often overlap,” Tallahassee Rabbi Shneur Zalman Oirechman told lawmakers. “And while one can criticize any government, make no mistakes, attempts to delegitimize Israel, the State of Israel, and calls that Jews do not have the right to self determination in their own land are anti-Semitism”

Anyone listening in on Tuesday morning’s discussion might be under the impression that HB 741 has no opposition, but that’s not the case.

“We see this as very troublesome because it hinders our first amendment rights and also... it’s an inequitable bill that caters only to one of the multiple religious minorities that face discrimination on a regular basis in Florida,” said Wilfredo Ruiz, Communications Director for the Florida chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR-Florida), the largest Muslim civil rights organization in the state.

Ruiz said anti-Semitism and the recent uptick in anti-Semitic incidents and crime in Florida are issues that do need to be addressed, but he’s concerned this bill ignores the xenophobia experienced by Muslims, Sikhs and other religious minorities.

And he said the bill deliberately conflates anti-Semitism with legitimate criticisms of the State of Israel.

“Criticizing Israel for inter religious tensions or political tensions is criminalised in this bill. Ordering an investigation of the State of Israel for human rights violation could be seen as a crime as well,” he said. “So to criminalize those first amendment protected expressions is a problem that this bill brings, convoluted with the legitimate purpose of protecting the Jewish community from anti-Semitism.”

Ruiz worries that in the current political climate people will be too scared of being labeled an anti-Semite to speak out against this proposal. And he thinks that climate was deliberately fostered.

“Why didn't they separate this bill on anti-Semitism and do another bill on equating criticism of Israel to anti-Semitism?” he asked, rhetorically. “They have convoluted on whole purpose because they know that people will feel apprehensive from criticizing this.”

The bill still has to make it through the Education and Judiciary Committees before it goes to the House floor for a full vote. The Senate companion bill, SB 1272, was filed by Sarasota Republican and Chairman of the Florida Republican Party Joe Gruters.

Photo used under Creative Commons license.

Brendan Rivers can be reached at, 904-358-6396 or on Twitter at @BrendanRivers.

Special Projects Producer Brendan Rivers joined WJCT News in August of 2018 after several years as a reporter and then News Director at Southern Stone Communications, which owns and operates several radio stations in the Daytona Beach area.