Jacksonville Attorney Investigating Downtown Protest; JSO Reviewing Protocol

Apr 10, 2017

JSO officers arrested five protesters Friday evening in Hemming Park. The arrests were captured on cell phone video.
Credit News4Jax

Jacksonville attorney John Phillips said he’s conducting a review of what happened during a Hemming Park protest Friday as he prepares to represent at least one of those arrested.

Several protesters were arrested during a demonstration against last week’s U.S. airstrikes in Syria. Philips said he’s reviewing all available evidence of what led to the arrests.

“We start today and we’re going to investigate,” he said on “First Coast Connect” Monday. “We don’t do just an over the weekend investigation and say this crime was violated or not. We're goign to investigate all the parties.”

As widely circulated videos show, chaos broke out between protesters, one counter-protester and police. Five protesters were arrested on felony charges, including inciting a riot, resisting arrest and battery on an officer.

One shaky video showed what looks like the start of the scuffle with police when a counter-protester, who said his name is Gary Snow, gives a middle finger to protester Connell Crooms. When Crooms appears to lunge toward Snow, police took Crooms down. Snow said protesters were taking his belongings.

“They were the first ones to engage and I reacted and retrieved my property and after that incident things got heated and escalated and that’s when JSO had stepped in,” said Snow on “First Coast Connect.”

Snow was not arrested, and police said Crooms was the violent aggressor. A video showed several officers trying to arrest Crooms, who was hospitalized. Some observers are outraged, including his mother, Felicia Crooms saying it was brutality because he’s deaf. They said he couldn’t hear police commands.

Wells Todd with the Progressive Coalition, one of the groups who led the protest, said he’s considering a lawsuit against JSO.  

“We’re holding Sheriff Williams and the police department here responsible for what happened and we’re asking for a public apology and we’re asking the city to pay for damages,” Todd said.

Other videos show Snow, prior to the incident, with a large Donald Trump flag yelling over protesters and getting on stage with them. Protesters asked police to remove him from the stage, but they did not.

Counter-protester Gary Snow and protesters David Schneider and Connell Crooms who were arrested, stand on stage at Hemming Park.
Credit Twitter

Snow regularly counter-protests events seen as anti-Trump or anti-police, he said in a Facebook video. There’s also a video online of Snow burning and shooting a Pan-African flag. He said in a Facebook video he did it in response to groups burning the American flag.

“I actually stand up to racism,” Snow said. “Racism comes in any form and any color. We have a new movement in America called black supremacy and black nationalists.”

He denies he was trying to incite a riot, as protesters claimed.

Jacksonville Sheriff Mike Williams said in an emailed statement officers don’t tell groups where to stand during protests.

“As per protest planning protocol, we don’t tell groups where to go, but we do tell them what they can and cannot lawfully do — and specifically what actions may result in arrest,” he said.

He said protesters are encouraged to respond to agitators in a calm demeanor and must refrain from physical violence. However, he said the incident has prompted him to look into how JSO manages protests.

“I am working with my leadership team to determine what new protocols may be put into place to successfully manage these events moving forward,” Williams said.

Listen to this story on Redux

Reporter Lindsey Kilbride can be reached at lkilbride@wjct.org, 904-358-6359 or on Twitter at @lindskilbride.