Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Available On Air Stations

Same Sex Ex Denied Visitation

Second District Court of Appeal Chief Judge Craig Vilanti ruled a woman who was raising children with her same-sex partner cannot claim visitation rights.
Second District Court of Appeal Chief Judge Craig Vilanti ruled a woman who was raising children with her same-sex partner cannot claim visitation rights.

The Second District Court of Appeal has ruled a woman doesn’t have visitation rights to the children she raised with a same-sex partner.

Second District Court of Appeal Chief Judge Craig Vilanti ruled a woman who was raising children with her same-sex partner cannot claim visitation rights.
Credit Second District Court of Appeal
Second District Court of Appeal Chief Judge Craig Vilanti ruled a woman who was raising children with her same-sex partner cannot claim visitation rights.

According to court records, Elizabeth Pasik and Susan Russell were raising the children together until they split up in 2011. The appellate court says granting Pasik visitation would violate Russell’s privacy rights as a parent.

But Lambda Legal, a civil rights group, says the court got it wrong. Senior Attorney Beth Littrell, says Russell gave up that right when she agreed to raise her children with a partner.

“Where a parent intentionally creates a family unit with another adult, then no constitutional violation takes place. And that should have been the decision of the court.”

Lambda is one of a handful of advocacy groups that filed friend of the court briefs. In his ruling, Chief Judge Craig Vilanti said he sympathizes with Pasik, but the Legislature needs to clarify the law.

Copyright 2015 WFSU